ADVERTISEMENT

Frenemies Forever: Tracing the 25-Yr History Amidst Amma and Swamy

The two leaders have locked horns several times in the last decade.

Published
Politics
6 min read


BJP leader Subramanian Swamy and AIDMK Chief Jayalalithaa share a troubled relation. (Photo Courtesy: The News Minute)

On Tuesday, as Tamil Nadu’s caretaker Governor Vidyasagar Rao reallocated cabinet portfolios handled by the state’s Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa to her senior-most cabinet colleague O Panneerselvam, one man claimed credit for the move.

Jayalalithaa’s frenemy and BJP leader Subramanian Swamy tweeted that the appointment of Panneerselvam as the person who would chair TN cabinet meetings was triggered by his demand for President’s rule.

In the last two years, especially from the time of Jayalalithaa’s conviction in the disproportionate assets case, the two leaders have locked horns several times.

BJP leader Subramanian Swamy tweeted that the appointment of Panneerselvam was triggered by his demand. (Photo: PTI)
BJP leader Subramanian Swamy tweeted that the appointment of Panneerselvam was triggered by his demand. (Photo: PTI)

In 2015, several defamation complaints were filed against Subramanian Swamy after he told the PM that Jayalalithaa was pushing for the release of boats captured by the Sri Lankan navy as most mechanised boats belonged to her aide Sasikala.

Jayalalithaa and Subramanian Swamy share a long and troubled history.

ADVERTISEMENT

Relationship Goes Back to 1992

It dates back to 1992, and started with a proposal to divest the Tamil Nadu Industrial Development Corporation (TIDCO). The chairman of TIDCO was an IAS officer named Chandralekha. She opposed the divestment of state-owned TIDCO's stakes in Southern Petrochemicals Industries Corporation (SPIC).

Chandralekha argued that this would result in losses for the government, and her opposition made the government pull back its decision. Some weeks later, Chandralekha became the victim of an acid attack that left her horribly burned. The Chandralekha case became a huge political controversy in Tamil Nadu as some linked it with the SPIC-TIDCO divestment issue and suspected the hand of powerful people behind the crime.

Chandralekha got support from a politician in Tamil Nadu – Janata party leader Subramanian Swamy. Soon she joined his party and the duo was vocal in their opposition about the AIADMK leader.

Swamy with Chandralekha



In October 1992, Swamy filed a petition to the State Governor demanding Jayalalithaa be disqualified as an MLA . (Photo Courtesy: The News Minute)
In October 1992, Swamy filed a petition to the State Governor demanding Jayalalithaa be disqualified as an MLA . (Photo Courtesy: The News Minute)

In the same year, another controversy broke out as properties belonging to the Tamil Nadu Small Industries Corporation (TANSI) was purchased by Jaya Publications and Sasi Enterprises, a company in which Jayalalithaa and Sasikala were partners.

Subramanian Swamy was one of the petitioners who approached the court, alleging that the property was undervalued and sold to the firms, causing a loss of over 3.5 crore to the state government. (Jayalalithaa was acquitted in that case by the Madras High Court in December 2001, and later, the Supreme Court confirmed the acquittal in November 2003.)

In October 1992, Swamy filed a petition to the State Governor demanding Jayalalithaa be disqualified as an MLA (Under Article 192 of the Constitution of India), as she was a partner in Jaya Publications, a private company that had entered into a contract with the government.

ADVERTISEMENT

In 1995, continuing his campaign against Jayalalithaa, he gave a memorandum to the Governor seeking sanction for prosecution on several charges. On 1 April 1995, Governor Channa Reddy gave sanction to prosecute her in two cases – TANSI case and the Coal deal.

Retaliation by Jayalalithaa

 Tamil Nadu CM Jayalalithaa has never been the one to keep quiet. (Photo: Reuters)
Tamil Nadu CM Jayalalithaa has never been the one to keep quiet. (Photo: Reuters)

But Jayalalithaa was not one to keep quiet.

In 1995, Swamy created a furore by calling LTTE supremo V Prabhakaran, an international “pariah" – a term of Tamil origin that is derogatory to Dalits. The Jaya government filed a case against him under the Protection of Civil Rights Act.

An India Today profile on Swamy says that in 1995 “with the Jayalalithaa government out to arrest him, he was forced to undergo an image makeover, changing to suits and dyeing his hair to evade the police. To mollify the Dalits, he went to the extent of assuring them to get the Oxford English Dictionary to remove the term ‘pariah’”.

The slam match continued for many months. Back then, Swamy supported a group called 'Nallaatchi Iyakkam' comprising himself, former Assembly Speaker K Rajaram and a few former AIADMK leaders. When Swamy came to the Sessions Court in connection with filing a complaint, he was heckled by AIADMK cadre, and a few of his supporters and members of the Nallatchi Iyakkam were beaten up.

But by then Swamy’s image as an anti-corruption crusader was soaring in the state and he managed to poll more than a lakh votes from Madurai constituency, where he contested from in the 1996 Lok Sabha elections.

It was Subramanian Swamy who also filed a complaint against Jayalalithaa in 1996, alleging that during her tenure as chief minister from 1991 to 1996, there was a big and disproportionate jump in her wealth.

ADVERTISEMENT

After the DMK returned to power in 1996, the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption investigated her wealth and filed its own charge-sheet. She was convicted in that case 18 years later, with a special court in Bengaluru handing out a four-year imprisonment term to her. The Karnataka HC later acquitted her and an appeal is pending with the Supreme Court.

DMK Chief M Karunanidhi assumed power in 1996. (Photo Courtesy: The News Minute)
DMK Chief M Karunanidhi assumed power in 1996. (Photo Courtesy: The News Minute)

Now back to 1996. The first thaw in relations came in December 1996, when Jayalalithaa was arrested and jailed for a few weeks by the Karunanidhi-led DMK government that had assumed power that year. Subramanian Swamy had told Rediff in an interview in 1999 that:

Jayalalithaa had approached me three years ago when she was in jail, saying she did not want to fight with me anymore and she would like my help in her fight against M Karunanidhi. I have nothing personal against anybody, but I told her that I would not withdraw the cases that I had filed against her. And I agreed to work with her if she agreed to be a different person. We worked together but I think a couple of things queered the pitch.

Lull Before the Storm

Later, in a surprise move, Jayalalithaa withdrew her candidate in the first Mayoral elections for Chennai city and supported Janata Party candidate Chandralekha, the acid attack survivor.

Chandralekha lost the election, but the gesture from Jayalalithaa mended the ties between the two for a while. In 1998, she formed an alliance with the Janata party and Swamy contested from the Madurai seat which he won during the 1998 general elections.

It was reported then that Jayalalithaa had lobbied hard to make Swamy the finance minister, but Atal Bihari Vajpayee who apparently detested Swamy, did not pay heed.

In April 1999, Swamy hosted the famous tea party that brought together Congress President Sonia Gandhi and Jayalalithaa.

ADVERTISEMENT

Final Severing of Ties

Frenemies Forever: Tracing the 25-Yr History Amidst Amma and Swamy

Though his intention was to bring down the Vajpayee government, Sonia Gandhi insisted that the Congress would come into the picture only if the AIADMK withdrew support. Ultimately, Jaya gave the letter of withdrawal of support on 14 April, 1999.

From 1999 to 2014, Jayalalithaa and Subramaniam Swamy have kept each other at arm’s length. There were only minor skirmishes or bursts of support in this period.

(Published in an arrangement with the News Minute)

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

ADVERTISEMENT
Stay Updated

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter And Get News Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.

Join over 120,000 subscribers!
ADVERTISEMENT