ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

Did Nehru and Mahatma Gandhi Refuse to Represent Bhagat Singh During His Trials?

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

Updated
WebQoof
6 min read
story-hero-img
i
Aa
Aa
Small
Aa
Medium
Aa
Large
Hindi Female

A message doing the rounds on social media claims that Mahatma Gandhi, former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, and Muhammad Ali Jinnah were top lawyers of their time, but none of them represented Bhagat Singh during his trials.

However, there are no historical records and documents to support this claim.

To understand this, it is important to know that Singh faced two trials: the Central Assembly bombing case (1929) and the murder of the British police officer John Saunders in 1928 (Lahore conspiracy case), for which he was sentenced to death.

As per the proceedings of the Lahore conspiracy case, Singh had put in an application stating that he wanted a legal adviser to watch the proceedings and give him advice on the line of cross-examination.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD
It clearly stated that the adviser will neither cross-examine nor address the court, and for this he chose Lala Duni Chand.

For the Central Assembly case, as per the proceedings, BK Dutt and Singh were represented by counsel Asaf Ali. But historian AG Noorani notes in his book 'The Trial of Bhagat Singh' that Singh refused to be represented by a lawyer and "wished to have the services of a legal adviser". The same was mentioned in an article published in The Hindu.

WHAT'S THE CLAIM?

A right-wing Twitter user, Rishi Bagree, tweeted, "Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, and Mohd Ali Jinnah were top lawyers & barristers of their time, yet none represented #BhagatSingh legally. Why?"

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

An archive of the post can be seen here.

(Source: Twitter/Screenshot)

Similar claims were shared by several social media users which can be seen here, here and here.

0

WHO REPRESENTED BHAGAT SINGH?

Bhagat Singh faced two trials:

  • Central Assembly Bombing case: Trial started on 7 May 1929

  • Murder of Saunders (Lahore conspiracy case): Trial began on 10 July 1929

TRIAL 1: ASSEMBLY BOMBING CASE

According to digitalised documents available on Indian Culture portal, preserved and uploaded by the National Archives of India, Bhagat Singh and Batukeshwar Dutt were arrested for throwing bombs in the Central Legislative Assembly in Delhi on 8 April 1929. The duo were arrested under IPC sections and the Explosive Substances Act.

The trial began on 7 May 1929 and ended on 12 June 1929. In this case, the nationalist counsel Asaf Ali represented both the accused, as per these records.

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

Ali represented both Singh and Dutt.

(Source: Indian Culture Portal - proceedings/ Screenshot)

However, eminent historian AG Noorani notes in his book 'The Trial of Bhagat Singh, that Singh refused to be represented by a lawyer.

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

Speaking to The Quint, Professor Chaman Lal, honorary advisor to Bhagat Singh Archives and Resource Centre, said that Asaf Ali represented Dutt, but was only a legal counsel to Singh in Delhi case.

By law, Asaf Ali was only Dutt's lawyer, but Singh took advice from him for his case. However, Singh insisted on writing the legal statements himself. So, Ali did have a connection with Singh legally but he was just a legal counsellor.
Professor Chaman Lal
ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

TRIAL 2: MURDER OF SAUNDERS

In this case, Singh was given the death sentence, along with Sukhdev Thapar and Shivaram Rajguru, for killing Assistant Superintendent Saunders.

They were hanged on 23 March 1931.

During the trial, Singh chose to have a legal adviser. An excerpt from Noorani's book reads, "Bhagat Singh chose as his legal adviser Lala Duni Chand, one of the political leaders who had participated in the protest movement against the Simon Commission.

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

An excerpt from Noorani's book.

(Source: The Trial of Bhagat Singh — Politics of Justice/ Screenshot)

Another excerpt from the book carried a letter written by Singh to his father, Sardar Kishan Singh Sandhu, where he clarifies that he does not require a lawyer.

"There was no need to engage a lawyer. But I want to take legal opinion on certain matters, but they are not so important," the letter said.
In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

An excerpt from Noorani's book.

(Source: The Trial of Bhagat Singh — Politics of Justice/ Screenshot)

We also checked digitalised documents related to the Lahore Conspiracy Case of 1930 on the Indian Culture portal.

It clearly mentioned that Singh had voluntarily put an application request only for a legal adviser and not for a lawyer, who will neither cross-examine nor address the court.

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

Lahore Conspiracy Case, 1930 proceedings from Indian Culture portal.

(Source: Indian Culture portal/ Screenshot)

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

Lal further explained, "There was a lot of good lawyers in Lahore. Many of them represented many revolutionaries, some boycotted the proceedings totally, some engaged full time counsels. But Singh sought only legal adviser to advise him, while he and few others represented their own case."

Another eminent historian, S Irfan Habib, added that many leaders, including Jawaharlal Nehru and Mahatma Gandhi, were in touch with Singh, but nobody raised a question of representing him since he did not wish to be represented.

"There is no question of anybody representing him. These claims are all rubbish talks to bring Nehru and Gandhi down."
S Irfan Habib, Historian

WHAT KIND OF SUPPORT DID SINGH GET FROM THESE LEADERS?

We found an archive of Jawaharlal Nehru's autobiography, 'Toward Freedom', which was published in 1941. In the book, Nehru clearly mentions that he met Singh at Lahore jail while the latter was fasting.

An excerpt from the book reads:

"I happened to be in Lahore when the hunger strike was already a month old. I was given permission to visit some of the prisoners in the prison, and I availed myself of this. I saw Bhagat Singh for the first time, and Jatindranath Das and a few others. They were all very weak and bedridden, and it was hardly possible to talk to them much. Bhagat Singh had an attractive, intellectual face, remarkably calm and peaceful. There seemed to be no anger in it."

In Noorani's book, one chapter is dedicated to how Mohammad Ali Jinnah defended Singh in the Central Assembly meeting 1929.

The book quotes Jinnah as saying, "The man who goes on hunger-strike has a soul. He is moved by that soul and he believes in the justice of his cause; he is not an ordinary criminal who is guilty of cold-blooded, sordid, wicked crime."

He added that he did not approve Singh's actions, but he blamed the "damnable system of Government" that is resented by the public which is bringing in violent reactions.

In reality, Bhagat Singh didn't want anybody to represent him legally.

An excerpt from Noorani's book.

(Source: The Trial of Bhagat Singh — Politics of Justice/ Screenshot)

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

'Gandhi's Truth' chapter in the same book reveals that Mahatma Gandhi had written letters Lord Irwin asking for the Singh's execution to be suspended.

It also states that Gandhi found Singh's actions of bombing and murdering very gruesome and revolting and that is why he refrained from visiting Singh in the prison.

Clearly, the claim that takes a dig at Nehru and Gandhi for not helping Singh's legal trial are misleading. Bhagat Singh was known to have fought his legal battles on his own with legal advice from some lawyers.

(Not convinced of a post or information you came across online and want it verified? Send us the details on WhatsApp at 9643651818, or e-mail it to us at webqoof@thequint.com and we'll fact-check it for you. You can also read all our fact-checked stories here.)

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Read Latest News and Breaking News at The Quint, browse for more from news and webqoof

Topics:  Congress   Bhagat Singh   Webqoof 

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD
Published: 
Speaking truth to power requires allies like you.
Become a Member
3 months
12 months
12 months
Check Member Benefits
Read More
×
×