Silly Souls Row: Cafe Owners Deny Links With Irani, Cite Portuguese Civil Code

The Portugese Civil Code transfers the property rights of a man to his wife after his death.

Union Minister Smriti Irani with Silly Souls Cafe and Bar in the background. Representational image. 

(Photo: Altered by The Quint)

A Portuguese era law, which transfers the property ownership rights of a man to his wife after his death, has been cited in defense by the owners of a restaurant in Assagao village in North Goa, which the Congress claimed was linked to Union Minister Smriti Irani's daughter.

An activist-lawyer had filed a complaint, in which he alleged that the license to run the upmarket restaurant - 'Silly Souls Cafe and Bar' - was obtained "illegally" and that it was renewed this year in the name of a person who died in 2021.

The Congress had last week alleged Irani's daughter was linked to the property, a charge rejected by the minister.

During the first hearing in the case conducted by state Excise Commissioner Narayan Gad on Friday, 29 July, the family members of Anthony DGama, in whose name the license for the restaurant was issued, told the authorities that it is entirely their business and no other person is involved in it.

‘Property Jointly Owned by Husband & Wife’

Talking to reporters after the hearing, Advocate Benny Nazareth, who represents the DGama family, said the Portuguese Civil Code mandates that when a spouse dies, his or her powers are transferred to the partner.

He said that the application for renewal of the license was done by the family members after the death of Anthony.

The Portuguese Civil Code is still in force in Goa.

Social activist and lawyer Aires Rodrigues, who is the complainant in the case, had pointed out to the excise commissioner that the renewal of licence was sought on behalf of Anthony, more than a year after his death.

Anthony DGama's son Dean was present during the hearing of the case.

The lawyer representing the DGama family said that as per the Portuguese Civil Code, the ownership of the property is jointly done in the name of husband and wife.

"But when the husband dies, the power is automatically transferred to the spouse. So nothing actually needs to be done further," he added.

Meanwhile, Merlyn, the wife of late DGama, in her written submission dismissed all the allegations made by Rodrigues in his complaint before the excise commissioner.

On Friday, while posting the next hearing in the matter for 22 August, the excise commissioner had framed two issues for determination, the first one being whether the excise license was obtained on the basis of false and inadequate documents and through misrepresentation of facts, while the second one is whether there were any procedural irregularities on the part of the excise officials.