How Long Can Kashmir Afford Martyrs to Different Causes?

For three decades, no one has been able to solve the paradox of one ‘martyr’ killing another in Kashmir.

3 min read

Two martyrs, two ideologies, two funerals and two mourning families. Kashmir's saga of tragedy and destruction could not have a more poignant symbolism as these funerals took place when the world was welcoming another New Year.

Hundreds attended the funeral of Fardeen Ahmad Khandey, the 16-year-old boy who celebrated his impending "martyrdom" through a spine-chilling video in which he said: "Jihad, the holy war, had to be carried on as the doors of freedom can only be opened with the blood-soaked hands of martyrs."


This is the first time after over a decade in the bloody 30-year-long history of separatist violence in Kashmir that local boys carried out a "Fidayeen" (suicide) attack with one of them celebrating the perceived martyrdom with absolute motivation.

As hundreds attended the funerals of two “martyrs”, Fardeen and Manzoor Baba, another “martyr” of a different cause was buried in Budgam district’s Nagam village.

Sharif-ud-Din Ganai had joined the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) eight years back. He was killed when security forces were fighting to flush out Fardeen and Baba at the training centre in Pulwama district's Lethpora town.

Ganai was buried as his parents, brothers and relatives mourned the death of their sole breadwinner who had joined the security forces for a secure future.

  • 01/04
    CRPF personnel fire in air to give gun salute to constable Sharif ud Din Ganai during his funeral in Srinagar on Sunday, 31 December.(Photo: PTI)
  • 02/04
    Large number of people carrying the body of CRPF constable Sharif ud Din Ganai during his funeral procession on 31 December.(Photo: PTI)
  • 03/04
    People offering funeral prayers of CRPF constable Sharif ud Din Ganai on 31 December.(Photo: PTI)
  • 04/04
    Family members of CRPF constable Sharif ud Din Ganai crying during his funeral procession on 31 December.(Photo: PTI)
It was a paradox that nobody has been able to resolve for nearly three decades in Kashmir – the paradox of one martyr killing another and both believing that they have a place in heaven that must be earned – one, by shedding blood of innocents and the other for defending them. But both bring inconsolable tears to their families.

These martyrs to different causes and ideologies died when the world was celebrating the beginning of 2018 and praying for peace, prosperity and hope.

Security forces say over 200 militants were killed in Kashmir and nearly half-a-dozen others came back to their families after joining militant ranks during 2017.

Suicide attacks have occurred in Kashmir in the past as well, but these had mostly been carried out by foreign militants. Local boys joining "suicide squads" of militant outfits has definitely dampened hopes that normalcy was around the corner in the beleaguered state.


An intelligence officer, requesting not to be named, said:

What is more disturbing is the fact that young boys motivated to such extreme levels do not necessarily belong to poor or under-privileged families. Fardeen was the son of a serving cop and the family is relatively better off.

One man's martyr is another man's traitor. This maxim may hold good for the unenviable situation the people of Kashmir are facing and yet this provides little consolation to families being destroyed.

Local boys are celebrating so-called martyrdom when they should have been celebrating careers and professions. In whatever little or large numbers such "celebrating martyrs" might exist here, unless the last of them is convinced that life is a greater celebration than death, hopes of a peaceful future would continue to elude, underlined by the coffins reaching the families and disrupting their lives.

(This article was published in an arrangement with IANS.)

(This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for the same.)


(Breathe In, Breathe Out: Are you finding it tough to breathe polluted air? Join hands with FIT in partnership with #MyRightToBreathe to find a solution to pollution. Send in your suggestions to or WhatsApp @ +919999008335)

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Speaking truth to power requires allies like you.
Become a Member
Read More