Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?

US Defence Secretary stated on record that he held discussions over human rights issues with Indian ministers.

Published
WebQoof
4 min read
NDTV’s report is based on statements made by the US Secretary of Defence on record.
i

Several social media users falsely claimed that NDTV peddled ‘fake news’ after the media house published a report on the visit of US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin to India.

Based on statements made by Austin in a press briefing in Delhi on 20 March, NDTV reported that he held talks with Indian ministers over human rights issues in the country. Despite the statement being on record, users falsely called NDTV out for spreading ‘fake news.’

While, the Indian government has not issued a formal denial, users attached a screenshot of a tweet by news agency ANI, wherein sources ‘confirmed’ that the US defence secretary did not talk about human rights.

CLAIM

User Avinash Srivastava shared the claim, garnering over 5,700 likes at the time of writing this article.

You can view an archived version <a href="https://archive.is/d5ebd">here</a>.
You can view an archived version here.
(Photo: Twitter/Screenshot)

The claim was shared by several other users on Twitter and Facebook.

  • You can view an archived version <a href="https://archive.is/ysMYi">here</a>.
  • You can view an archived version <a href="https://archive.is/RP9ju">here</a>.

Facebook page ‘Presstitutes’ also shared the claim, garnering over 1,200 likes at the time of writing this article.

You can view an archived version <a href="https://perma.cc/H2S3-5RT6">here</a>.
You can view an archived version here.
(Photo: Facebook/Screenshot)

WHAT WE FOUND

While concluding his three-day visit to India, the US Secretary of Defence stated that he discussed human rights issues with ministers, in a press conference held at Delhi. A transcript of the conference is available on the US government’s official website for the Department of Defence.

Austin was asked by a reporter if he had a chance to “question of violations of the human rights especially against Muslim minorities” with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. He replied that while he did not have an opportunity to discuss it with PM Modi, he brought up the issue with other members of the Cabinet.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: defense.gov/Screenshot)

Human rights were also brought up in another question, wherein a reporter referred to a letter by the chairperson of the Senate foreign relations committee, Senator Robert Menendez to Austin. The Senator had demanded that Austin urge India to uphold human rights and democratic values.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: defense.gov/Screenshot)

WHAT DID NDTV AND ANI REPORT?

NDTV’s report carried quotes from the briefing verbatim.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: NDTV/Screenshot)

A video of the press conference can also be seen here. News agency PTI had also reported that discussions on human rights were held.

Further, ANI had also reported on 20 March, that the Defence Secretary had brought up the issue of human rights in his talks with the Indian ministers.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: ANI/Screenshot)

Naveen Kapoor, the National Bureau Chief of ANI also tweeted the same.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: Twitter/Screenshot)

However, on 21 March, ANI tweeted that “high-level Indian sources” have confirmed “that there was no discussion of human rights in India with US Defence Secretary Lloyd J Austin III.” ANI’s report can be viewed here.

Did US Defence Secy Discuss Human Rights Issue With Indian Min?
(Photo: Twitter/Screenshot)
It must be noted that the Indian government has not issued a formal denial yet.

Discussions on human rights issues in the country are crucial in the backdrop of reports declaring India an ‘electoral autocracy’ instead of a democracy. US-based human rights watchdog Freedom House had also said that India has fallen from ‘Free’ to ‘Partly Free’ status since PM Narendra Modi took over in 2014.

Evidently, NDTV’s report is based on statements made by the US Secretary of Defence on record.

(Not convinced of a post or information you came across online and want it verified? Send us the details on WhatsApp at 9643651818, or e-mail it to us at webqoof@thequint.com and we'll fact-check it for you. You can also read all our fact-checked stories here.)

(The Quint is available on Telegram. For handpicked stories every day, subscribe to us on Telegram)

Stay Updated

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter And Get News Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.

Join over 120,000 subscribers!