'Direct' Rail Connectivity to Kashmir Isn't All That Direct. Here's Why

Fears and expectations are running high as the final upgradation on the 272-km-long Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla rail link is approaching completion. This will result in an uninterrupted railway line connecting the Kashmir Valley – where road access remains fraught with climate-related risks – to the rest of the country. Built at an estimated cost of Rs 41,000 crore, the said project has been described by Union Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw as "the most difficult railway project undertaken since Independence".Speed trials were recently held on the 17 km Katra-Reasi section of the rail link which marks the last milestone to the process of laying the tracks running between the Valley and Jammu. The latter is already connected to the Indian railway network.Delhi Elections: 5 Reasons Why BJP isn't Declaring a CM CandidateOn 16 January, the commissioner of railway safety completed its final inspection of the 17 km section, after the completion of which the train will tear through the Pir Panjal mountain range of Jammu, and traversing a series of high-altitude bridges, chug into the scenic climes of the snow-bound town of Banihal, which abuts the Valley at its gateway. From there, the line will merge with the Qazigund-Baramulla railway line (connecting the southern and northern parts of Kashmir) that is already operational – albeit developed in phases – since 2009. Last week, however, a new twist in the whole scheme of things dampened the anticipation. According to a new timetable issued by the Indian Railways, one Vande Bharat Express and two Mail Express trains will run daily between the railway stations of Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Katra in Jammu and Srinagar in Kashmir.The timetable doesn’t say anything about the journey of the trains beyond Katra, leading to speculations that there won’t be a direct train service running uninterrupted between Kashmir and the rest of the country.These apprehensions were compounded by news reports which said that on account of security concerns, passengers will have to disembark at Katra and then pass through another round of checks before switching to a Kashmir-bound train.Although the reports were based on quotes from anonymous railway officials, the Ministry of Railways hasn’t rebutted them, indicating that they might not be unsubstantiated. Dallewal's Fast Completes 50 Days: Why Hasn't Modi Govt Responded? 3 ReasonsThe direct train connection between Kashmir and the mainland has been a subject of intense debates in recent times. Although the project was initiated 30 years back, its completion and operationalisation is taking place amid the larger discourse about the erstwhile state’s ‘complete assimilation’ with the rest of the country.Originally conceived in 1994, the service only began to materialise in Kashmir in 2008 when the train commute became possible between Anantnag in South Kashmir to Pattan in the North. A year later, the service was extended to Baramulla on one side and to Qazigund on the other. In 2013, the Qazigund line was extended across the mountains into Banihal in Jammu.Separately, the railways in 2014 extended the Udhampur line in Jammu (already operational since 2004) to Katra in the Reasi district which fans out into the craggy mountain ranges of Pir Panjal that gather around the Kashmir Valley on its southern side. With this upgradation, the only portion which wasn’t yet connected through railways was the Katra-Banihal section. Owing to its difficult topography composed of rugged hills, ravines, mountain spurs, rivers and wide valleys, the construction of railway tracks was initially deemed impossible. But over the past decade, the Indian Railways pulled off this seemingly miraculous task. Of 111 kms of this stretch, 98 kms are just tunnels that slice through the tough mountainous terrain. The section is also composed of 37 bridges – of which some have been described as engineering marvels, such as the Chenab Bridge, the world's highest railway bridge (359 meters), and Anji Khad Bridge, the country’s first cable-stayed railway bridge.Last year in February, Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the rail service extending the Banihal line further south towards Sangaldan, shortening the distance with Katra further. The next phase (which will conclude this month) will fill up this gap consisting of four more stations, completely linking Kashmir with the rest of the country via an all-weather train track. Indian Cricket Isn’t Shampoo, Restrain on Wives Isn’t ‘5 Problems, 1 Solution’Within the Valley, the debates over railway connectivity have generated anxieties over the demographic changes that might take place as a consequence of enhanced mobility into the region where road accessibility remains cut off in the event of bad weather. In the southern plains in Jammu, the trading community apprehends that a direct train to Kashmir will lead to them being ignored.At the same time, however, there are hopes that train connectivity will usher in a period of economic boom as manual labour will become cheaper and imports-exports from and towards the mainland will grow manifold.Already beset by the controversy over his perceived deference to the BJP-led Union government, Chief Minister Omar Abdullah initially sought to justify the one-stop arrangement, saying that it was conceived keeping in mind the security of passengers. “If there are security concerns, then I don’t think there should be any objections,” he told the media. “After all, whosoever travels by train wishes for their safety and security, and so do we.”Other regional leaders from political groups like the Apni Party and the People’s Democratic Party, however, slammed the decision, calling it 'humiliating' and an 'unnecessary burden', respectively.Sensing that the news has triggered a sense of dismay in several quarters, Omar nuanced his position."Check the train passengers in Katra or Jammu sure but NO change of train will be supported by us. That said there is no concrete proposal and when there is we will give our inputs and suggestions."Omar AbdullahKashmir-based observers believe that adding a halting station to the rail journey between Jammu and the Valley defeats the whole purpose of train travel. "If we look at the time schedule of Vande Bharat trains, they take 6 hours to reach Jammu from Delhi, and an additional 2 hours to reach Katra from which the train will reach Srinagar in 3 hours 10 minutes. So, from the perspective of someone who plans to travel from Srinagar to Jammu, if it takes me just 5 hours, then it looks fine. But if I am supposed to halt at a station and spend 2 more hours interchanging into another train, then a road trip via a cab is more desirable for me instead because that will take me just 4.5 hours."Ahmed Ali Fayyaz, veteran Kashmiri journalist‘Emergency’ Review: Kangana Ranaut Looks the Part in a Middling, Confusing FilmThe economic experts, however, have weighed the situation differently, saying that even if the train journey isn’t going to be direct, it will still boost the local economy."It is going to amp up economic activity. Trains will be helpful in bringing in more raw material and finished goods. It will make things cheaper here. Some manufacturers will face competition, but others will thrive. The migrant workers always feel a sense of disconnect with this land. But now the manufacturing sector will have access to a large pool of skilled labour. Predictability will come there as the closing of roads will no longer have any adverse impact."Ejaz Ayoub, Srinagar-based economistImran Murtaza, who heads Snack-a-Boo, a food processing unit in Srinagar, told The Quint that 45 of his 50 employees are migrants from other regions."The train connectivity is a positive development for someone like me as my employees will find it easier to commute between seasons."Imran Murtaza, head of a Srinagar-based food processing unit(Shakir Mir is an independent journalist. He has also written for The Wire, Article 14, Caravan Magazine, Firstpost, The Times of India and more. He tweets at @shakirmir. This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for the same.)

BECOME A MEMBER

'Direct' Rail Connectivity to Kashmir Isn't All That Direct

Kashmir-bound passengers will have to disembark at Katra and then pass through another round of security checks.