Things Manto Told Me: Stories of Reading and Discovering 

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?

5 min read
Hindi Female

Upar di gur gur di annex di be dhyana di mung di daal of the lantern,” are the strange words of Toba Tek Singh’s protagonist, the ‘lunatic’ Bishan Singh.

Fast forward to our digital age where words are but wind; they lose relevance almost as soon as they gain it. In such times, if some words manage to stay afloat in the lazy stream of one’s memory, they truly ought to be remarkable.

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
Pankaj Kapur as Bishan Singh in the short film Toba Tek Singh.
(Photo: YouTube Screenshot)

Bishan Singh’s remarkable words, penned by the ‘seer of Pakistan’ – Sa’adat Hasan Manto – came to me at an unremarkable moment of frustration, and then they kept returning, effortlessly from memory, at timely intervals.

Then there were more words, and sometimes whole characters made appearances, conversing in loud whispers around me.

Manto told me many things through his works. Here are some of them.


Literature for Life’s Sake

Essays have been written on what Bishan Singh’s apparently meaningless words imply. Essays that left my 19-year-old nervous self, who had just begun her literature degree, perplexed.

A few years later, when I went back to my alma mater to collect the degree, I looked over my shoulder to find excited first-year students — another generation of millennials — casually flipping through their course books.

I said to a friend, “Wait till these newbies read Manto, their minds will be blown!”

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
Manto spoke to my 19-year-old self of an India that I only knew through facts.
(Photo Courtesy: Wikipedia)
Manto spoke to my 19-year-old self of an India that I read about only in dull history books, an India I only knew through facts, and hardly through emotion.

Besides Toba Tek Singh — a story, in some senses, about no man’s land that becomes every man’s business — Manto wrote a number of stories on partition.

In a lesser known work titled Dekh Kabira Roya (Kabir Saw and Wept), written soon after Manto’s migration to newly-created Pakistan, the character of Kabir (fashioned after the 15th century Sufi poet Bhagat Kabir) is continually asked by those around as to why he is crying.

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
An 1825 CE painting depicting Bhagat Kabir weaving.
(Photo Courtesy: Wikipedia)
Kabir, lamenting the partition of India, responds, “I cried so that you can understand whether literature is for literature’s sake or for life’s sake.”

Manto’s literature definitely fell in the latter category.


Lost and Gained in Translation

An accidental acquaintance with Urdu led me to Manto’s Bu (Odour).

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
A typewritten extract from Manto’s short story Bu.
(Photo Courtesy: The Friday Times)
Saari raat Randheer ko uske jism se ek ajeeb qism ki bu aati rahi thi. Iss bu ko jo ba-yak-vaqt khushbu bhi thi aur badbu bhi... vo saari raat peeta raha.
Sa’adat Hasan Manto, Bu

“A strange smell wafting from her body flooded his senses all night — a smell at once pleasant and nauseating.” (translated by Muhammad Umar Memon).

The sense of smell conveyed in Urdu — a language only recently familiar to me, and a language in which Manto himself flunked twice in the school-leaving examination — got lost in the English translation of the story.

Only after reading the story in Urdu could I fully gauge what it meant for something to be lost in translation. Only then could I think in another language.

While something is lost in translation, something, I believe, is also gained. Most of all, the translations — and there are some good ones out there, thanks to extensive scholarship on the author — make Manto’s stories accessible to a wider readership.


Of Obscenity and Revolution

Talking of readership, a friend once asked, “What’s with these revolutionary writer types being so obscene ya?” He had chanced upon one of my old course books and read a little.

That book, I must confess, was a cocktail of obscenity and revolution. Manto’s Toba Tek Singh was bound with Ismat Chughtai’s Lihaf (The Quilt). Need I say more?

Manto was tried for obscenity six times, both in undivided India and Pakistan, for his stories Bu (Odour), Kali Shalwar (The Black Shalwar), and Thanda Gosht (Cold Meat) among others.

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
Nawazuddin Siddiqui as Manto, the ‘serial offender’.
(Photo Courtesy: Facebook/Manto Film)
Defending his works in one such trial, Manto said, “If you cannot bear my stories, it is because we live in unbearable times.”
Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?

Wonder what Manto would have to say about our current age, but that’s a story for another time.

To explain the idea of absurd moral standards that we uphold as a society — because let’s face it, my friend was going to hear nothing of that — I took him to a performance of Manto Ki Auratein, a play that gives a voice to the ‘ashleel’ (‘shameless’) and unrelenting women from different walks of life, as Manto did in his stories.

Was I able to convince my friend of Manto’s brilliance? Definitely. He later borrowed several of my books on the author and never returned them.


“Who tells the greatest story, God or Manto?” is a question sometimes asked by his fans, not simply because of his infamous epitaph, penned by him one year before his death, wherein he wrote, “Under tons of earth he lies, wondering if he is a greater short story writer than god.”

Who is the greatest storyteller – God or Manto?
“Who tells the greatest story, God or Manto?”
(Photo Courtesy: Twitter)

God or not, modern adaptations and renditions of his writings and continuing interest in his life and times are proof enough that Manto still holds the power to raise storms and inspire change at a time that needs it the most.


(This article was first published on 17 January 2018. It is being reposted from our archives to mark Saadat Hasan Manto's birth anniversary)

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Read Latest News and Breaking News at The Quint, browse for more from neon

Topics:  literature   Nandita Das   Urdu 

Speaking truth to power requires allies like you.
Become a Member
3 months
12 months
12 months
Check Member Benefits
Read More