PN Haksar was Indira Gandhi’s ‘Moral Compass’: Jairam Ramesh

Indira Gandhi & PN Haksar briefly parted ways in 1973 over Sanjay Gandhi’s Maruti row: Congress MP Jairam Ramesh

Congress MP Jairam Ramesh describes PN Haksar as Indira Gandhi’s “ideological anchor and moral compass”.

(Photo: File/Altered by Arnica Kala/The Quint)

Video Editor: Vishal Kumar
Camera: Shiv Kumar Maurya

“Nationalisation of banks, the ideological split in the Congress party, the war with Pakistan, the creation of Bangladesh, the cutting to size of President Nixon and Henry Kissinger, the Indo-Soviet treaty of 1971, the Simla Agreement of 1972 and the Delhi Agreement of 1973. These magnificent achievements of Indira Gandhi, the political leader, were made possible by PN Haksar who was functioning as her alter ego,” said Congress MP Jairam Ramesh.

In a chat with The Quint, Jairam Ramesh hails PN Haksar as the most powerful civil servant that India has had in the last 70 years. According to Ramesh, he played a pivotal role in defining Indira Gandhi’s politics and decision-making from 1967-1973.

He defined their relationship, the years of their association, estrangement and the years after separation.

PN Haksar and Indira Gandhi had a friendship going back to the 1930s. Along with Feroze Gandhi, they formed a trio who worked under Krishna Menon in the India League. When she became Prime Minister in 1966, she was constantly thinking of ways to bring him back. Finally, in May 1967, he becomes her Secretary and continues in that position till January 1973.

Jairam Ramesh to <b>The Quint</b>

File photo of PN Haksar in conversation with Indira Gandhi.  

Haksar Shaped Indira Gandhi’s Politics

In 1967, socialist MP Madhu Limaye described Indira Gandhi as a “dumb doll”. And according to Ramesh, Indira Gandhi “dreaded” the Parliament in her initial years. But Haksar used to carefully write out whatever she had to say in Parliament – whether they were short statements, spontaneous interventions or long speeches.

Haksar was forever giving Indira Gandhi the courage of his conviction and for six to seven years, the courage of his conviction converged with the courage of her conviction. It was not just a professional relationship; she had implicit faith and trust in him because of their family relationship.

Jairam Ramesh to <b>The Quint</b>

Opening session at the Simla Summit, June 1972.

Haksar played a great role in shaping Indira Gandhi’s foreign policy.

“The Indo-Soviet Treaty, which was a milestone, was possible because of Haksar. He was the one who sold it to Mrs Gandhi after Kissinger's air dash to China from Rawalpindi in 1971,” said Ramesh. Then the opening up of India to Iran and the establishment of a special relationship with France, according to Ramesh, was because of PN Haksar.

Sanjay Gandhi’s Ambitious Maruti Project Led to the Fallout

Recalling the incident that led to the fallout between Indira Gandhi and PN Haksar, Ramesh tells The Quint that the estrangement was entirely because of Sanjay Gandhi’s Maruti episode. Sanjay Gandhi wanted to unveil a Maruti car project in India, but Haksar had two major objections:

• First, he was opposed to a passenger car project per se. He said India must invest in public transport and that India didn’t require passenger cars as there already were passenger car manufacturers at that time. India, he thought, needed two-wheelers but, most importantly, it required public transport. So, that was an ideological objection.
• His second objection was that as the son of a prime minister, Sanjay Gandhi "should not be doing this kind of a business venture”.

By mid-December 1972, Haksar had made it clear to Indira Gandhi that he would quit. According to Ramesh, Indira Gandhi made no special effort to hold him back. Perhaps, she knew he had made up his mind.

Haksar Continued to be PM’s Special Envoy

Indira Gandhi flanked by Aziz Ahmed (left) and Haksar in New Delhi, August 1973. 

Even after PN Haksar quit Indira Gandhi’s secretariat in 1973, in Ramesh’s words, “Gandhi continues to use Haksar”.

She uses him as a special envoy to Iran, as a special envoy to Pakistan and Bangladesh. She uses him as a special envoy to France and, finally, in January 1975, she brings him back as Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission; she is the Chairman and you know it is a position of great authority.

Jairam Ramesh to <b>The Quint</b>

Ramesh recalls Haksar’s role in paving the path for then-PM Rajiv Gandhi’s historic visit to Beijing, in December 1988, as a special envoy tasked with reconciling with China.

Contrasting Personalities: Indira Was ‘Pragmatic’, Haksar A ‘Marxist’

Ramesh describes Indira Gandhi and PN Haksar as having two contrasting personalities. Ramesh holds the view that Indira Gandhi became more “pragmatic” after 1980s, while PN Haksar remained an “unrepentant Marxist”.

Mrs Gandhi went from begin strong left of centre to somebody who was, perhaps, at the centre looking for a new opening to the western economy, particularly the United States. But Haksar remained frozen in time.&nbsp;

Jairam Ramesh to <b>The Quint</b>

Haksar alongside Indira Gandhi at a workshop in July 1975. 

According to Ramesh, Haksar never compromised with his feelings. He said and wrote what he felt. But Gandhi was more conscious of what she did.

“A politician has to change, but an ideologue doesn’t. Haksar was an ideologue.”