ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

Police Action Against Veterans Shows Growing Civil-Military Rift

After watching the police brutality on retired officers, will young men be motivated to join the army?

Published
Blogs
4 min read
story-hero-img
i
Aa
Aa
Small
Aa
Medium
Aa
Large
Hindi Female

Whatever may be the merits or demerits of the ongoing agitation by a group of armed forces veterans at the Jantar Mantar site in Lutyen's Delhi, the treatment meted out to them by the Delhi Police on 30 October 2017 marks a dark day for Indian democracy.

The armed forces have been mandated by the Constitution to safeguard, not only the nation, but the statute as well. Veterans of the armed forces form a pool of trained and disciplined manpower, with nationalism ingrained in them, and need to be treated as assets.

The armed forces form an important pillar of national strength and its members willingly forgo many of their fundamental rights and basic necessities of a dignified life to ensure the safety of the nation's frontiers.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

The Constitution mandates them to carry their ranks with them even after retirement. The Constitution recognises the uniqueness of the Indian armed forces and their members, both serving and retired.

How did Delhi Police dare to treat veterans and ladies in the manner they did in front of cameras? The same police forces are the first to disappear whenever a serious law and order problem occurs — and the army is called in to rescue them and handle the adversity. At whose behest did they display such brutality against peaceful veterans?

The courage, discipline, sense of sacrifice and love for the nation among veterans needs to be imbibed in every citizen of this country if we wish to become a superpower. Their ill-treatment can have long-term implications on national security and can be ignored at its own peril by the government.

0

In this era of electronic and social media, which has penetrated all frontiers, news travels instantly. The police action against veterans can lead to alienation of a large segment of disciplined and patriotic people. It definitely will adversely impact the morale of the serving soldiers.

It is not only that today's serving soldier is tomorrow's veteran, but that today's veterans are also fathers, grandfathers, uncles and other relatives of the serving soldiers. The blood of those who would have watched the high-handedness of the police or read about it must be boiling, but the discipline ingrained in them prevents them from reacting.

Money spent towards the modernisation of the armed forces cannot compensate for the morale of the man behind the gun. It is ultimate and the nation has watched the grit, determination and high morale of the Indian army soldier on the barren and daunting heights of Kargil. Can the nation afford to have the morale of its soldiers in their boots? Imagine the impact it would have on national security.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

Will any young man who would have watched the police brutality against the senior retired officers be ever motivated to join the armed forces? If the armed forces fail the nation in future, will the responsibility for their down slide be owned by the political leadership or the bureaucracy?

Civilian control of the armed forces does not imply control by those in civvies.

In the garb of civilian control, the bureaucracy in India is trying to control the armed forces, negating their uniqueness as enshrined in the Constitution. In fact, Jantar Mantar is the manifestation of the growing civil-military divide in our country towards which every successive government has contributed.

The state of affairs is not only saddening but alarming. The bureaucracy is hell bent to downgrade the status and financial equivalence of the armed forces, which becomes obvious with every Pay Commission report since the third Pay Commission.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

The armed forces make up 30 percent of the government's work force. That they are not represented in any Pay Commission displays the disdain with which successive governments have treated them. The serving soldiers and veterans are only demanding their due and not looking for any extraordinary largesse, they are fighting for their izzat (pride) and status that have been continuously eroded by the babudom in Delhi.

The warrant of precedence is tweaked to suit the convenience of the bureaucrats. A Major General was equated to a Joint Secretary with 30 years' service. The 30-year clause has been conveniently removed and today a Joint Secretary with 18 years of service equates himself with a Major General.

Nowhere in the world are police allowed to wear the badges of ranks of the army except in India, to achieve a false sense of equivalence.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD

The most ridiculous is an attempt to equate the ranks with the Armed Forces HQ services cadre which was raised as a subordinate support cadre to assist the armed forces officers so that the availability of serving officers in active units was not affected. How can commissioned officers be equated with any other service, let alone a subordinate service? It happens only in India in the garb of civilian supremacy.

The present government granted One Rank One Pension (OROP), which the previous governments denied. There was dissatisfaction in some quarters and the government accepted that anomalies exist. The one-man Justice Jeevan Reddy Commission was appointed in 2016 and submitted its report in November 2016, but its contents are yet to be made public. The neglect is hurting the veterans, eroding the credibility of the government and adding to the widening civil-military rift.

ADVERTISEMENTREMOVE AD
The Ministry of Defence, supposedly the custodian of the interests of the armed forces, is the most distrusted organ of the state as far as serving soldiers and veterans are concerned.

The distrust is due to substantial acts of omission and commission. The government needs to act immediately to stop this trend and act on various reports submitted concerning the revamping of the ministry and integration of Armed Forces HQ with it.

(The author is a Jammu-based political commentator, columnist and strategic analyst. The article has been published in arrangement with IANS. This is a personal blog and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for the same.)

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Read Latest News and Breaking News at The Quint, browse for more from voices and blogs

Speaking truth to power requires allies like you.
Become a Member
3 months
12 months
12 months
Check Member Benefits
Read More
×
×