Former captains Sunil Gavaskar and Kapil Dev have said a few of the recommendations made by the Lodha Panel were too harsh, such as one vote for one state and the cooling off period of three years for administrators.
The two stalwarts felt BCCI has a different structure to control and work with and hence all the recommendations made by the panel may not be beneficial.
“I feel the thing about one state one vote is a little bit hard on associations that are founding members of the Board. If you go to England, you will find that not every County plays the English County Championships. Not every state plays in Australia’s first-class championship (Sheffield Shield). Therefore, to have every state play Ranji Trophy is going to dilute the level of cricket and not help us at the international level,” Gavaskar reasoned.
“What is being done at the moment where teams play junior level is if you do well you get promoted. Like Chhattisgarh did well at junior level, therefore they have been promoted and that is the way to go. You just can’t have states giving direct entry into Ranji Trophy,” he added further when fellow commentator Sanjay Manjrekar sought his viewpoint on the Lodha panel recommendations during the ongoing first cricket Test between India and New Zealand.
Kapil, on his part, feels these are all “teething a problem” and said while he found many recommendations reasonable, a few were still harsh.
“Some things that I come to know, delight me. There is an age (limit) for everybody. There is one year left for me to be a selector, fine because it says 60 years. But I could not understand that Maharashtra can have only one vote. How can a place like Mumbai which has done so much for cricket, vote only after three years?
“Some of the recommendations, I feel are too much. Lets’ not take anything away from the BCCI. They have looked after this game for 60-80 years. I think one has to be more calm and easy and see what is best for the game. I don’t believe in hire and fire,” Kapil said.
(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)