'Can't Get Into Suitability': Supreme Court On Justice Gowri's Appointment

Citing reasons for dismissing the plea against appointment of Justice Gowri to the Madras High Court, the Supreme Court on Friday, said that it cannot examine the suitability but only the eligibility of a candidate recommended for judgeship.A bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and BR Gavai said:"We have gone through Constitution bench judgments and said we cannot get into suitability of the candidate."The same bench had dismissed the plea filed by Madras High Court lawyers challenging Justice Gowri's appointment, on 7 February but gave reasons for dismissing the plea on Friday, 10 February.Why the challenge? The petitioners had flagged hate speeches allegedly made by her against Muslims and Christians, in their challenge to her eligibility."There is letter and spirit of every word in constitution. She had rendered herself incapable of taking oath due to her utterances," Advocate Raju Ramachandran, appearing for the petitioners, submitted before the court.The backstory: On 17 January, the Supreme Court Collegium recommended Victoria Gowri for judgeship at the Madras High Court.Following this, on 1 February, Madras High Court Bar advocates wrote to President Draupadi Murmu and the Collegium, demanding that her recommendation be withdrawn and the President return the file recommending Gowri's appointment."Can a litigant belonging to Muslim of Christian community ever hope to get justice in her court, if she becomes a judge?" they wrote.“We write, with a sense of foreboding, in these troubled times, when the judiciary is facing unprecedented and unwarranted criticism from the executivive, as we are apprehensive that appointments such as these may pave the way for undermining the independence of the judiciary," the signatories to the letter added.Following this, the government, based on the Collegium's recommendation notified Gowri's appointment on Monday, 7 February.On the same day, a writ petition, challenging her eligibility for the post was filed for urgent listing before Chief Justice DY Chandrachud.The hearing: While her oath taking ceremony was underway, the apex court was hearing the plea.The hearing was supposed to take place at 9:30 am (an hour and five minutes before the oath taking ceremony) but was postponed to 10:30 am.Govt & Collegium: What Justice Gowri's Minority Bias Says About Judicial ChoicesJustice Gowri's BJP links:According to reports, Gowri was appointed state in-charge of the BJP's Kerala Mahila Morcha, or women’s wing, on 8 October 2010. She also campaigned for the national party in the run-up to the 2014 general election in Tamil Nadu. Additionally, an unverified Twitter account allegedly belonging to Gowri claimed in its bio that she was the National General Secretary of BJP Mahila Morcha.Justice Gowri's Controversial Comments:"If the Islamic terror is green terror, the Christian terror is white terror."Lekshmana Chandra Victoria Gowri"Both (Christian groups and Islamic groups) are equally dangerous in the context of conversion, especially Love Jihad."Lekshmana Chandra Victoria GowriThese and other comments made by her are part of her interviews titled 'The More Threat to National Security & Peace? Jihad or Christian Missionary?’ and ‘Cultural genocide by Christian Missionaries in Bharat.'She also wrote a piece for an RSS publication on 1 October 2012, which said:“But not a finger is lifted to stop allured and coerced conversions and to prevent Christians from conceiving communal conflicts,” and “for fifty year the marginalised Hindus have been fighting the mighty Christian diocese. But now the situation is out of control.”(With inputs from LiveLaw)Victoria Gowri Takes Oath as Judge, SC Dismisses Plea Against Appointment

BECOME A MEMBER

'Can't Get Into Suitability': Supreme Court On Justice Gowri's Appointment

The petitioners had flagged hate speeches allegedly made by her, in their challenge to her eligibility.

Read Latest News and Breaking News at The Quint, browse for more from news and law

Topics: L Victoria Gowri