India Fears Deal to Cut Aviation Emissions May Not Be ‘Equitable’

India has proposed key changes in an international deal to restrain aviation emissions.

Published
Environment
3 min read
The aviation industry contributes 2 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions. (Photo Courtesy: Bernal Saboria/India Climate Dialogue)

Even as representatives from close to 200 nations meet in Montreal to hammer out a deal to contain aviation emissions, India has expressed its reservations on a global agreement unless some key concerns are addressed.

(We’ll decide) once the nuts and bolts become clearer. Until then, our fears are that it is not equitable.
Ashok Gajapathi Raju, Aviation Minister told Reuters in Montreal

Representatives from almost 200 countries are meeting in Montreal since Tuesday to negotiate an agreement for the first-ever global ceiling on carbon emissions from international flights.

Delegates at the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) conference will for the next two weeks to 7 October work out a deal that makes the entire aviation sector carbon neutral by 2020 and then bring down emissions to 2005 level by 2050.

People demonstrate during a protest march ahead of the 2015 Paris Climate Conference, known as the COP21 summit, along Strasse des 17 June in Berlin. (Photo: Reuters)
People demonstrate during a protest march ahead of the 2015 Paris Climate Conference, known as the COP21 summit, along Strasse des 17 June in Berlin. (Photo: Reuters)

Around 60 ICAO countries, including the United States and the European Union nations, have indicated their support. Some including India, Russia and China have voiced concerns.

The aviation industry internationally is responsible for 2 percent of global greenhouse emissions. If it were a country, it would have been the seventh largest polluter (similar to Germany), according to Carbon Brief, an information provider. In addition, there is the fact that air travel is most likely to double by 2030.

Aligning with Paris

India has been vocal in its opposition to measures that would increase costs. The proposed global market-based measures (GMBM) by ICAO must be aligned with the relevant provisions of the Paris Agreement, it has demanded with some other emerging countries, including Brazil and South Africa.

These provisions relate to the common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities (CBDR-RC) principle, which ask the rich nations to cut emission on priority because they have been historically bigger polluters. An offset programme, on the other hand, could impose an economic burden on developing countries trying to expand their aviation sectors.

“The interests of poor and developing countries should be taken on board in the development of the global market-based measures,” India’s environment minister Anil Madhav Dave had said when ICAO President Olumuyiwa Benard Aliu visited New Delhi in August, the Times of India reported.

If an agreement is reached in Montreal in October, it will be the first global carbon-reduction deal for an entire industry.  (Photo: Reuters)
If an agreement is reached in Montreal in October, it will be the first global carbon-reduction deal for an entire industry. (Photo: Reuters)

The Montreal meeting is expected to draw in enough countries that will agree to participate in the initial voluntary phase till 2027 that covers more than 80 percent of the emissions. Several countries with fast-growing aviation sectors, including Brazil and India, are most likely to wait until the deal becomes mandatory in 2027. This is in a scenario when they agree to participate in the agreement in the first place.

If an agreement is reached in Montreal in October, it will be the first global carbon-reduction deal for an entire industry. The broad contours of the pact are also supported by aviation trade groups. Industry leaders are pushing nations to join the agreement, which would require the companies to offset their emissions growth by funding environmental initiatives. The measures may eventually cost the aviation players around USD 24 billion every year, according to a BloombergQuint report.

The 15-year agreement will not force airlines to cut pollution. Instead, companies will compensate for emissions growth from 2020 by buying credits that back renewable energy development, forest preservation and other similar measures. According to estimates by airlines, the annual industry-wide cost may be USD 23.9 billion by 2035, or 1.8 percent of projected revenue, Bloomberg said.

Although environmentalists have largely supported the proposed deal, they criticise the fact that it is voluntary for the first six years. Many of them also say that the proposed low cost of environmental offsets could let companies off easy.

(The article was originally published on India Climate Dialogue.)

Liked this story? We'll send you more. Subscribe to The Quint's newsletter and get selected stories delivered to your inbox every day. Click to get started.

The Quint is available on Telegram & WhatsApp too, click to join.

Stay Updated

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter And Get News Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.

Join over 120,000 subscribers!