Walayar Sisters Death: Kerala HC Orders Retrial, Reinvestigation 

The Kerala government had told the HC that it does not object to a retrial and a reinvestigation in the case.

3 min read
Kerala High Court sets aside a lower court order.

In a huge relief to the parents of two girls who died in Walayar in Kerala, the Kerala High Court on Wednesday set aside a lower court order, that acquitted the accused and has ordered a retrial into the case.

The Kerala High Court bench of Justices, comprising of A Hariprasad and MR Anita, has ordered all the four accused in the case to appear before the trial court on 20 January.

Livelaw reported that the High Court has given the prosecution liberty to seek further investigation in the case.

The High Court’s decision comes after the mother of the two girls, aged 13 and 9, who were found dead a few days apart in 2017, started a campaign for justice. The High Court has asked the accused in the case to present before the trial court on 20 January.

The elder daughter was found hanging on 13 January 2017, and the younger one was found hanging in the same shed, days later, on 4 March. The younger one had testified seeing her sister’s killers. Four accused – V Madhu, M Madu, Pradeep Kumar, and a juvenile boy – were first arrested in the case.

In October 2019, the Palakkad Special Court had acquitted all the four accused in the case — V Madhu, M Madu, Pradeep Kumar, and a juvenile boy. However, in November last year, Pradeep was found dead at his residence in Alappuzha. Police suspect that he took his own life.

The Kerala government had approached the High Court last year in October seeking to set aside the verdict given by the Palakkad special court.

The government stated in court that the special court had acquitted the accused based on the oral testimony from the witnesses as key evidence. "The lower court seriously erred in disbelieving the eyewitness accounts of the parents of the victims and even disbelieved the testimony of the girls’ mother,” the government wrote in its appeal.

Advocate Nasar, who appeared for the government, said:

“The government’s first plea was to conduct a fresh probe. The division bench of the High Court has set aside the Palakkad POCSO court’s verdict and has sent back the cases to the trial court for a retrial. The High Court has also pointed out crucial shortcomings on the part of the prosecutors and investigators of the case. The High Court has even listed out the lapses of the trial court.”

Notably, he also said that the High Court had directed the lower court that if the investigation agency gives a request for a re-investigation in the case, the same should be granted.

“The court also directed that if the prosecutor in the case wants, the witnesses can again be examined in the court. Even new witnesses can be examined during the trial.”

The mother of the two girls had accused the police of incorrectly recording and manipulating her statement. She had alleged that two women police personnel posing as members of the Women's Cell of the Palakkad police, recorded her statement.

"The statement was taken without any direction from any of the senior officials or from the court. The statement was written by the police in a manner so as to portray the deaths as suicides. The mother told the police officials that her elder daughter was killed, but in the statement, it was written that she had died," Marson, who leads the Walayar Justice Forum, had told TNM.

A Judicial Commission appointed by the government submitted a report in April 2020 that there were lapses during the trial of the case. The High Court in March had ordered the arrest of the four acquitted accused persons in the case. This was on a plea filed by the government and the mother.

(This story was first published on The News Minute and has been republished with permission.)

(The Quint is available on Telegram. For handpicked stories every day, subscribe to us on Telegram)

Stay Updated

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter And Get News Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.

Join over 120,000 subscribers!