PM Modi Faces Criticism for not Aiding Distressed Farmers

Even after the weather department’s warning, the Modi government failed to tackle the issue of less rainfall.

3 min read
A farm worker walking across a dried paddy field on the outskirts of Ahmedabad. (Photo: Reuters)

India has just suffered back-to-back drought years for only the fourth time in over a century. Summer crops are wilting and reservoir water levels are at their lowest in at least a decade for the time of year.

Yet Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government has not held a high-level meeting to discuss drought relief for farmers since June, when its weather office forecast –correctly as it turned out – that this year’s monsoon rains would fall short.

Parched lands of a lake in India. (Photo: Reuetrs)
Parched lands of a lake in India. (Photo: Reuetrs)

Fifteen months since coming to power, in part on his record in boosting agriculture as chief minister of Gujarat, Modi faces growing criticism for failing to shield Indian farmers from deepening hardship.

“The whole government machinery became complacent,” said Ashok Gulati, an agricultural economist and former adviser to New Delhi. After rain in June, the government “took no precautionary measures” even as the weather turned dry, he said.

The lack of urgency risks worsening rural distress ahead of state elections Modi must win to stand a better chance of passing tough reforms.

The next to go to the polls is Bihar, home state of Radha Mohan Singh, the minister responsible for agriculture and farmers’ welfare.

Singh has been out campaigning in India’s third-largest state by population. A senior official at his ministry said the government was ready to help farmers deal with crop losses. But there were no plans for any new meetings, said the official, who requested anonymity.

The government was waiting for states to formally declare a drought before it could pass on benefits, Singh said on Tuesday.


Modi “Only Talks”

Meanwhile, across villages in the huge western state of Maharashtra, weeds grow through drooping sugarcane and soy bean crops. Rats infest sunbaked rice fields.

Rains were more than 40 percent below normal in central Maharashtra. Farmers there, worried that their crops will fail again, said they had lost hope with Modi.

He only talks. Since he came to power, nothing has changed for us.
— Nanasaheb Patil, 32, Rice Grower from Bamnoli

Patil got no government aid when unseasonal rain damaged his crops earlier this year.

Government subsidies aided harvest of staples like rice, wheat and sugar, resulting in lesser crop damage.

But for India’s nearly 200 million marginal farmers, many of whom borrow heavily to cultivate plots smaller than two acres, the fate of one crop can make the difference between life and death.

Reports of farmer suicides are rising, especially from the drought-hit Maharashtrian district of Marathwada.

According to local reports, nearly 600 farmers have committed suicde so far this year in Marathwada. Rains in the region were less than half normal levels.


Monsoon Misery

India’s June-September monsoon rains are so far 14 percent below normal due to El Nino, a weather pattern caused by Pacific Ocean warming.

El Nino can cause drought in South Asia. Rains were 12 percent deficient in 2014, cutting grains output by 4.7 percent in the year to June 2015.

The senior agriculture official said he did not foresee a major drop, against the speculation of decreased farm output, as the sown acreage has been robust.

This year, monsoon’s early retrieval could leave too little moisture for farmers to sow winter crops like wheat and rapeseed on time.

Even if we assume that there won’t be any contraction, the agriculture sector can’t grow beyond 2 percent in the 2015/16 fiscal year.
— Ashok Gulati, Agricultural Economist; Ex-Adviser to New Delhi

Winter crops, heavily dependent on water from reservoirs at 84 percent of average levels over the last decade, account for about half the grains output.

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Stay Updated

Subscribe To Our Daily Newsletter And Get News Delivered Straight To Your Inbox.

Join over 120,000 subscribers!