Orissa Image Falsely Claims Women in Kerala Upset Over LPG Hike

A viral image of a protest in Orissa was altered to claim that women in Kerala are more upset over LPG hike.

A viral image of protest in Orissa was edited to claim women in Kerala are more upset about hike in LPG price.

(Photo Courtesy: BoomLive)

Don’t fall for fake news, click here to check out The Quint’s WebQoof stories.

CLAIM

A widely shared article by Malayalam website Eyewitnessnews.in has used a 2017 image from Bhubaneswar to claim that women in Kerala are upset over the hike in LPG price rather than the Supreme Court’s order allowing women entry at Sabarimala.

The article has used the image as the lead picture and the headline in Malayalam says, ‘Women protest by showing gas cylinder bills to BJP leaders who visited homes in Kottarakara, Kollam to collect signatures on the Sabarimala issue’.

The original text says, “കൊല്ലം കൊട്ടാരക്കരയിൽ ശബരിമല വിഷയത്തിൽ ഒപ്പു ശേഖരണത്തിന് വീടുകളിൽ ചെന്ന ബിജെപി നേതാക്കൾക്ക് നേരെ ഗ്യാസ് സിലിണ്ടർ ബിൽ കാണിച്ചു സ്ത്രീകളുടെ പ്രതിഷേധം”

Eyewitnessnews’s Facebook post has received around 5,000 shares while left-leaning Facebook page We love CPIM shared the article, drawing over 2,000 shares.

Eyewitnessnews’s Facebook page shared the image and received around 5,000 shares.

Click here for the archived version of the post.

Facebook page We love CPIM saw an engagement of over 2,000 shares.

Click here for the archived version of the post.

The story was also shared on Facebook group SDPI Keralam which received around 100 shares.

The image was widely shared on Facebook groups as well.

Click here for the archived version of the post.

TRUE OF FALSE?

A quick search on Google Reverse image shows an article by Telegraph India from August 2017. Telegraph’s report says that the image is of a protest staged by the women’s wing of political party Biju Janata Dal (BJD) in Bhubaneswar, Orissa against the central government’s decision to phase out subsidy on LPG cylinders. The image was clicked by their reporter Ashwinee Pati. Click here to read the article.

The original image was published by Telegraph India in 2017, showed a Google Reverse image search.

ORIGINAL VS EDITED IMAGES

While Eyewitness’s article does not say that women protested using gas cylinders, it claimed that some women showed their LPG gas bills when BJP leaders asked them for signatures of support. Citing ‘reports’ the article claims, women asked them to fix the LPG rates before deciding whether women need to enter Sabarimala. It also says, BJP and Congress are working together to score politically, leaving people confused about their real political intentions.

BOOM did not find other Malayalam dailies reporting the incident. And, though the image of women holding the cylinder was not of Kerala, Eyewitness did not specify that it is a representational image. Moreover, it is evident that there were attempts to hide the fact that the photos are from Orissa.

A comparison of the original image and the image used by Eyewitness shows that it has been edited to cover the Oriya text in the banner behind the women. And, since the  image has been cropped, the scarves wrapped around their neck are not fully visible. However, the original picture (see the image on the right) shows that the scarves have the conch, BJD’s logo, printed on it.

The original image was edited by covering Oriya text in the banner behind the women.

BOOM also found another image of the protest from a website called WomanOdisha filed in August 2017. Below is a screenshot of the article.

Another website called WomanOdisha had shared the original image in 2017.

(Published in an arrangement with BoomLive)

(Not convinced of a story you came across on social media and want it verified? Send us the details at [e-mail] and we'll fact-check it for you. You can also read all our fact-checked stories here.)