Day 4: Blame Game Over Kashmir, NIT Bill High Points in Parliament

Catch all the live updates from both the Houses of the Parliament on day 4 of the monsoon session.
The Quint
Politics
Updated:
Rajya Sabha members discussing the issue of violence against members of the Dalit community on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)
Rajya Sabha members discussing the issue of violence against members of the Dalit community on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)
ADVERTISEMENT

  • Rajya Sabha adjourned till 11 am, Friday.
  • Lok Sabha adjourned for the day.
  • Mayawati comments on dismissal of Dayashankar Singh, the rights of Dalits.
  • Sharad Yadav, Ahmed Patel commence debate on Dalit violence.
  • Home Minister Rajnath Singh delivers statement on the Kashmir turmoil in Lok Sabha.
  • Rajnath Singh blames Pakistan for sponsoring the violence in Kashmir.
  • Committee to provide report on use of pellet guns within 2 months: Rajnath Singh.
  • Congress’ Jyotiraditya Schindia raised violence against Dalits in the Lok Sabha.
  • Schindia also condemned Dayashankar Singh’s comments about BSP supremo Mayawati.

Fall in People’s Faith in Politics, says Rajnath Singh

Home Minister Rajnath Singh talks about the impact the BJP government has made so far on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

Home Minister Rajnath Singh quoted statistics of Gujarat on murder, rape, and compared it to states like Bihar and the Uttar Pradesh which have a higher rate of these crimes. He also commented on the social and cultural milieu of the country.

I believe that post independence there has been a fall in people’s faith in politics and politicians...There should be at least one programme from each party to change social and cultural mindset. From time people couldn’t enter certain premises, now they are empowered financially through ‘Stand Up India’ and ‘Jan Dhan’. Give us credit at least for this, that our Government’s approach is positive and not negative!
Rajnath Singh, Home Minister

Mayawati Responds to BJP’s Decision to Oust Singh After ‘Prostitute’ Comment

BSP leader Mayawati raises the issues of Dalits being ignored justice by the BJP and Congress in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

Speaking in the Rajya Sabha, BSP leader Mayawati addressed two issues. She commented on BJP’s decision to remove Dayashankar Singh to remove him from his position as the Uttar Pradesh Vice President.

All leaders, especially minority and women leaders have condemned the remarks. They have boosted my morale. I’d hoped that the BJP would have filed FIR against Dayashankar after suspending him from post and party.
Mayawati, BSP Leader

The second issue she spoke about reservations for the SC/ST.

Congress in power -the longest and in highest numbers. Now the BJP has also served a total of eight years at the Centre since Independence. But even then there has not been enough progress in Dalit social and financial empowerment, there has been not even 50 percent benefit. The BJP celebrated its 125th birth anniversary but made no reservation for SC/ST in private sector or in higher judiciary... Forget about Dalits getting justice, even their FIR is not filed many times and the latest example is Una (Gujrat) incident.
Mayawati, BSP Leader

She also said that both the Congress as well as the BJP use Dalits as political weapons when they are in Opposition.

NIT Bill Met With Tharoor’s Offensive

Congress MP Shashi Tharoor launches offensive against the quality of education provided by the National Institutes of Technology (NIT) in the country.

The expenditure of Harvard University only exceeds the budget that Mr Jaitley has provided Mr Javadekar.
Shashi Tharoor
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor in response to the introduction of NIT bill in the Lok Sabha on Wednesday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: LSTV)

Comparing the condition of NITs to that of “small boats which collapse with the first wave”, Tharoor added that we should be building ships that can survive the oceans.

The attack was in response to the National Institutes of Technology, Science Education and Research (Amendment) Bill, 2016 that was introduced by Human Resource Development Minister Prakash Javadekar.

“I’m not opposing this bill...But we want these institutes to be solid ones,” says Tharoor.

Javdekar Responds to the NIT Bill, Says Students Have “Urge to Learn”

HRD Minister Prakash Javdekar speaks on the NIT bill in the Lok Sabha on Wednesday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: LSTV)

Minister of Human Resource Development also spoke on the NIT bill and said:

Many raised the issue of infrastructure. (Therefore) We are proposing a higher education funding to Cabinet, the budget also has Rs 1000 crore. All NIT and IIT campuses will be linked with industries, can customise research requirements -this will promote research. Interest free educational loan for those with annual income up to Rs. 9 lakh will also be provided.

Ahmed Patel Attacks Gujarat Model

Congress member Ahmed Patel claimed that the cracks in Narendra Modi’s Gujarat model have started showing through incidents like the violence in Una where members of the Dalit committee were assaulted for allegedly skinning dead cows.

Congress member Ahmed Patel in Rajya Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

The rate of atrocities against members of Dalit community has increased after 2014, Patel claimed citing crime data. He ended his speech with the following couplet.

<i>Bade nadaan have vo jo bulandi pe ghuroor karte hai. Humne sooraj ko bhi doobte dekha hai.</i>

Naive are those who feel proud about the heights they have reached. We have seen even the sun set.

Congress on Cow-Vigilantism

Rajya Sabha MP Sharad Yadav of JD(U) draws connection between unemployment and the rise of elements like gau rakshaks. It is the shame of not being able to provide employment that is stopping the government from putting an end of practices like cow-vigilantism.

JD(U) member Sharad Yadav speaks in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

Abraham Lincoln, leader of a country we try to emulate, gave up his life to save the downtrodden of his country, but India has not learnt nothing from him, Yadav said.

Rajnath Singh on Burhan Wani

Hizbul Mujahideen commander Burhan Wani was killed in an encounter with security forces who had intel on their position, Rajnath Singh said.

Wani used new age technology and social media to influence the youth of Kashmir, he added.

Our security forces did whatever they could. I believe non-lethal weapons should be used to stop a crowd. The number of people who have eye injuries is 53. Only one person has died due to non-lethal weapons. In 2010, the number of people who died due to non-lethal weapons was 6. I’m not blaming any government.
Rajnath Singh speaks in the Lok Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: LSTV)

Rajnath Singh says he will set up an expert committee who will provide a report over the merits and demerits of the use of pellet guns within two months.

He also claimed that the social media is used to spread wrong information like the viral picture of a child being stepped upon by a police official. He claimed that the picture is from an incident from Uttar Pradesh and he is aware of the people involved in the said incident.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Rajnath Singh on Kashmir in Lok Sabha

Home Minister Rajnath Singh makes his statement on the violence and loss of life in Jammu and Kashmir.

Home Minister Rajnath Singh speaks in the Lok Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: LSTV)

Singh repeated that Prime Minister Narendra Modi was on an international tour when the violence in Kashmir began but made it his first priority as soon as he returned to the country.

Pakistan is trying to divert the world’s attention from its failures by creating unrest in India. Pakistan does not need to worry about people who follow Islam and live in India.

The violence in Kashmir is sponsored by Pakistan which was created on the basis of religion, Singh claimed.

I do not wish to blame any government for the unrest in Kashmir. But when asks if one will succeed with continuous efforts? I say we will. despite the efforts of our neighbors.
Rajnath Singh, Home Minister in Lok Sabha

DMK MP Seeks CBI Inquiry In Case of Jr Doctor’s Death

DMK member Kanimozhi raised the case of a medical student studying at AIIMS, Sarvanan Ganeshan, who was found dead in his hostel room.

DMK member Kanimozhi in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

She has demanded that a special team or CBI inquiry into the matter as the police, she claimed, is keen on passing this as a suicide case, despite apparent evidence of this being a murder.

Congress Raises Issue of Weak Legal System

“The collegium has made suggestions but after NJAC judgement, the government seems to be angry,” Congress member Anand Sharma, who has also trained as a lawyer, said.

Congress member Anand Sharma in Rajay Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

Sharma reminded the House of the incident where Chief Justice of India TS Thakur broke down in presence of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Rigging in Rajya Sabha Election

Allegations of rigging of Rajya Sabha election in Haryana were raised by Congress member Shadi Lal Batra.

Congress MP Shadi Lal Batra in the Rajya Sabha on Thursday, 21 July 2016. (Photo Courtesy: RSTV)

Difference of ink was seen in the vote ballot paper. The Election Commission is investigating the matter but has found nothing. Batra has demanded a CBI inquiry in the matter.

Memorial for Mohammad Shahid

Biju Janata Dal (BJD) member Dilip Tirkey, former national-level hockey player, paid tribute to late hockey wizard Mohammad Shahid.

Hockey legend Mohammed Shahid passed away after battling kidney and liver problems at a Gurgaon hospital at 56.

Also Read
At 56, Hockey Legend Mohammad Shahid Passes Away

Shahid, from Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s constituency of Varanasi, should be honored with a memorial in his homeland, the members demanded.

Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi mentions that the government paid for his medical expenses.

What to Expect?

1. Comments about BSP supremo Mayawati by Dayashankar Singh and the protest against the comment may dominate the Parliament, although he has been suspended and the comment has been condemned by party members.

2. The debate and questions raised over violence in Kashmir by Congress member Jyotiraditya Schindia is scheduled to be continued in the Lok Sabha.

3. The following members are scheduled to hold a short-term discussion over the violence against Dalits in Una, Gujarat in the Rajya Sabha:

  • Sharad Yadav
  • Dr Satyanarayan Jatiya
  • Kahkashan Perween
  • PL Punia
  • Madhusudan Mistry
  • Pradeep Tamta
  • Mayawati
  • D Raja
  • Derek O Brien
  • Ghulam Nabi Azad
  • Anand Sharma
  • Shamsher Singh Dullo
  • Md Nadimul Haque
  • Ahamed Hassan

Other names scheduled to make an entrance in the session are Woman and Child Development Minister Maneka Gandhi and Minister of State for Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions Dr Jitendra Singh.

Over first three days of the monsoon session of the Parliament, these were the developments:

  • The Child Labour (Amendment) Bill was passed
  • Debate on the Kashmir issue was inititated
  • Violence against members of the Dalit community in Una, Gujarat discussed
  • Opposition raised Arunachal Pradesh (and Uttarakhand) issue
  • BJP’s Rajya Sabha MP Navjot Singh Sidhu resigned
  • Furore in both the Houses over vice president of BJP’s UP unit comparing BSP supremo to a prostitute

(At The Quint, we are answerable only to our audience. Play an active role in shaping our journalism by becoming a member. Because the truth is worth it.)

Published: 21 Jul 2016,11:00 AM IST

ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL FOR NEXT