Critics’ Verdict: ‘Secret Superstar’ Shines, yet Slides

What are the critics saying about the Zaira Wasim-Aamir Khan-starrer?

Aamir Khan in a still from Secret Superstar.

(Photo courtesy: Aamir Khan Productions)

Film: Secret Superstar
Director: Advait Chandan
Cast: Zaira Wasim, Aamir Khan, Meher Vij

Excerpts from reviews of Secret Superstar:

The deep pleasures of a simple story, simply yet eloquently told, is what makes Secret Superstar such an engaging, true watch. Till the first half. In the build-up, there is a refreshing absence of gimmicks, and diversions. Post-interval, it dips, and the result is a film which stops short of being superlative.  

Shubhra Gupta, Indian Express

It is that rare mainstream, unapologetically commercial Bollywood venture that places the spotlight firmly on domestic violence. It stars one of the biggest male stars in the history of Hindi cinema yet he is not the protagonist, nor does he position his role as a “guest appearance”... Secret Superstar is not merely about an issue, it is an entertaining, heartwarming saga of people and hope, of two luminous women who eke smiles and laughter out of their miserable lives... and of some female bonding.  

Anna MM Vetticad, Firstpost

Secret Superstar’s biggest asset is Aamir Khan. His comedy, even if it mostly slapstick in nature, is worth noticing. Zaira Wasim lives up to the expectations and the film has a message. In short, Secret Superstar has everything you ask for, but it isn’t exceptional storytelling. If there is one thing that can be blamed for it, it’s the overt melodrama. Imagine the same film without Aamir Khan and you’ll realise how Shakti Kumaarr has overpowered the real Secret Superstar and hence the theme of the film.  

Rohit Vats, Hindustan Times